Showing posts with label fat. Show all posts
Showing posts with label fat. Show all posts

Saturday, November 6, 2010

Up on the catwalk (7 December 2006)

Yesterday's Wall Street Journal had a story about Italy's attempts to ban too-thin models from Milan's fashion events:
"We believe we can favor models with a sunny, Mediterranean image, not fragile young women," Mr. Boselli [the head of the National Chamber for Italian Fashion, an industry group] said in an interview. "Optimistic-looking models are in line with Italian fashion."
This group has no actual authority and is reacting preemptively to the recent death of model Ana Carolina Reston from anorexia, so some cynicism as to what difference this will make in the long run may be warranted -- industry groups don't exactly have much incentive to enforce their voluntary guidelines; usually these announcements are meant to generate news stories (like this one) and disseminate the vague idea that the industry cares and is in the process of changing for the better. Whether or not anything actually changes will probably be determined by whether or not the sort of people who buy expensive clothes and send fashion ideas trickling down the trend chain hold them accountable. The article concludes with some taste-makers from American fashion magazines saying reasonable things.
If the movement does gather momentum, it could change the ways fashion houses design the clothes and looks that define their image world-wide. Some experts say it would actually bring looks more in line with what women associate with real, glamorous lifestyles. "I don't think that the public at large takes that many cues these days from the world of high fashion," says Sally Singer, fashion news and features editor at Vogue. "They're looking at celebrities and Hollywood -- what's cool for the public is filtered more through the celebrity lens these days. People buy fashion off the backs of famous people wearing them, not what a 14-year-old Eastern European model is wearing." Tom Julian, senior vice president and director of trends at McCann Erickson, says it does "add fuel to the fire" that Italy is drafting this charter. "If discussion of this topic continues in a global sense, it will challenge the American marketplace to rethink this -- we could see a visual shift from perfect models and aspirational lifestyles to more reality-based imaging," he says.
That would be nice, but let's face it, fashion is not about "reality-based" anything. And if you remove aspiration from the fashion industry, nothing would be left -- the whole industry revolves around manufacturing aspiration and distinction. Otherwise we'd all be wearing sensible shoes and comfortable, loose-fitting garments. Fashion is primarily a vehicle for vicarious fantasy, for aspirational daydreams about leisure, impracticality, luxury, and indulgence. It's about impossibility, and right now thin models connote that (at the ultimate price of their own health) the way fat models probably connoted an impossible plenitude to Rubens's patrons. The discussion going on is likely a distraction, while business in fashionland will go on as usual. It seems that post-production techniques can be used on photos to make them evoke the impossible without anyone having to starve themselves; but using women with actually impossible physiques is where the industry embraces an ethos of authenticity to underwrite the frivolity of the rest of the enterprise. The models suffer to provide that germ of reality upon which the rest of us can build the fantasies.

Friday, November 5, 2010

Fat taxes (18 October 2006)

Everybody's getting in on banning trans fats: New York City, Chicago, Disney, Pepsi, Wendy's. But why impose a ban when you could generate some revenue with a tax?

On his and fellow conservative Richard Posner's blog, (which is totally bizarre from a rhetorical point of view; it seems as though it were written by Spock), Gary Becker, an economist famous for treating human beings as a commodity (human capital), and performing economic analyses on drug addiction (it's rational) and domestic life (it's a factory), mulled over the implications of a tax on fat, which would be a less paternalistic way of ridding the world of trans fats (a.k.a. hyrdogenated oils) that clog arteries and cause obesity. (Some health officials go so far to compare hydrogenated oils to the threat posed by lead paint, but I think I'd feel substantially more comfortable with children eating doughnuts than paint chips.)

Becker is skeptical that the danger outweighs the social pleasure afforded by hamburger sandwiches and french-fried potatoes, and suspects that obesity is more attributable to kids' propensity for such "sedentary activities" as "listening to music on iPods and other devices." Kids spend too much time in front of computers, he suggests, and we wouldn't want to start imposing Pigovian taxes on Internet usage, would we? This seems like a red herring to me -- to find something more appealing to substitute for fat in order to make the argument against social engineering through taxes seem more salient. The same goes for when Becker, evoking the idea that obese citizens may stress the publicly financed health care system and should therefore be taxed to compensate for that (a la one of the rationales for cigarette taxes), shifts the subject to health-care savings accounts and consumer-driven health care, the preferred conservative nostrums for America's health care crisis.

Posner, in his reply to Becker, seems more cogent on the subject. He raises the point that obesity is correlated with poverty, so a fat tax would likely be regressive and would possibly fail to achieve its intended effect.
Indeed, high-caloric "junk food" might conceivably though improbably turn out to be the first real-world example of a "Giffen good," a good the demand for which rises when the price rises because the income effect dominates the substitution effect. A heavy tax on high-caloric food might so reduce the disposable income of the poor that they substituted such food for healthful food, since fatty foods tend to be very cheap and satisfying, and often nutritious as well.
But his main contention is that the rationale for a fat tax relies on the belief that people who eat fatty food are making informed rational choices and revelaing a preference for Ho-Hos and Doritos over broccoli. Posner, somewhat surprisingly, is willing to throw rational choice out the window here:
I don't think the fact that obesity is correlated with poverty is due entirely to the fact that fatty foods tend to be cheap as well as tasty and satisfying. I suspect that many of the people who become obese as a result of what they eat do not understand how, for example, something as innocuous as a soft drink can produce obesity. I also suspect that producers of soft drinks and other fatty foods are ingenious in setting biological traps -- designing foods that trigger intense pleasure reactions caused by brain structures formed in our ancestral environment (the prehistoric environment in which human beings attained approximately their current biological structure), when a taste for fatty foods had significant survival value.
Because of these biological traps, and the imperviousness of poor neighborhoods to nutrition education, Posner is willing to consider a ban of deceptively innocuous products like soft drinks: "And while generally parents know better than government what is good for their children, many parents who permit their children to drink soft drinks do not."

As much as I don't think the government should be telling people what they can and can't eat, it's hard to see the harm in disincentivizing food that makes for fat children. But the problem seems larger than the junk-food industry, which arises in response to generalized time crunch and the devaluation of time spent sharing a meal. I don't think the poor are necessarily ignorant about the ill effects of junk food, but they don't have the time to put into policing these questions or pursuing the frequently labor-intensive alternatives. We have developed a food infrastructure premised on the idea of delivering filling calories quickly to serve the need for convenience rather than nutrition. What may be needed is a proposal that could provide incentives for convenience, which is almost impossible to imagine, seeing how convenience virtually has become the definition of incentive.